| 1938 | Marjorie (Haisley) Holaday | 1941 | Independent |
| 1942 | Rachel (Quirk) Joyce | 1945 | Gamma |
| 1946 | R. Evelyn (Dixon) Langas | 1950 | Kappa Kappa |
| 1947 | Vera (Morgan) Roderick | 1949 | Psi Theta |
1948 | Muriel (Mathias) Billman | 1949 | Psi Theta |
1949 | Deloris (Ryan) Stottlemyer | 1952 | Alpha |
1950 | Martha Jane (Brunk) Randall | 1953 | Alpha Chi Omega |
| 1951 | Virginia (Petro) Owens | 1954 | Psi Theta |
| 1952 | Ann (Miller) Oliver | 1955 | Pi Beta Phi |
| 1953 | Mart (Kreider) Oliver | 1955 | Chi Omega |
| 1954 | Mary Lou (Hoover) Conrad | 1957 | Alpha Chi Omega |
1955 | Constance (Herron) Cotherman | 1958 | Chi Omega |
| 1956 | Barbara "Babs" (Denney) Petry | 1959 | Alpha Chi Omega |
| 1957 | Rosi (Fisher) Fullhart | 1958 | Delta Zeta |
1958 | Nicki (Negangard) Casterline | 1961 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
| 1959 | Judy (Claycomb) Doba | 1962 | Chi Omega |
1960 | Sue Ellen (Anstak) Lind | 1962 | Chi Omega |
| 1961 | Barb (Griffiths) Erickson | 1963 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1962 | Charlotte (Beach) Laterzo | 1965 | Pi Beta Phi |
| 1963 | Sharon (Gustavel) Costlow | 1966 | Pi Beta Phi |
| 1964 | Carla (Asherman) Thomas | 1967 | Chi Omega |
1965 | Vicki (Roller) Grafflin | 1967 | Alpha Chi Omega |
| 1966 | Paula (Stanifer) Powers | 1969 | Alpha Chi Omega |
| 1967 | Pamela (Whitestine) Schumann | 1969 | Delta Zeta |
1968 | Judith (Blaskovich) Butala | 1969 | Chi Omega |
1969 | Linda (Lee) Kelleher | 1970 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1970 | Rebecca (Kennedy) Maisenbacher | 1972 | Alpha Chi Omega |
1971 | Lynn (Beitelshees) Gibbs | 1973 | Delta Zeta |
1972 | Linda (Bouman) Williford | 1974 | Sigma Sigma Sigma |
1973 | Mary Ann (Myers) Meyer | 1975 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1974 | Michelle (Thames) Christopherson | 1976 | Independent |
1975 | Linda (Herr) Lindsey | 1976 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1976 | Katherine “Kate” (Klem) Kennedy | 1977 | Pi Beta Phi |
1977 | Tiann (Steinhilber) Coy | 1978 | Independent |
1978 | Jody (Hilles) Hoke | 1981 | Independent |
1979 | Kathleen (Walter) Eastman | 1981 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1980 | Carolyn (Cahill) Hayes | 1982 | Alpha Omicron Pi |
1981 | Jackie (Radpour) Rowles | 1982 | Chi Omega |
1982 | Sande (Schrier) Weiss | 1983 | Chi Omega–Sigma Chi |
1983 | Ana (Sanchez) Ave | 1984 | Alpha Chi Omega |
1984 | Amy (Lindop) Rohman | 1986 | Chi Omega |
1985 | Rebecca (Krebs) Stephens | 1986 | Chi Omega–St.A.R.T. |
1986 | Wendy (Morton) Kratzer
Troy Liggett | 1987
1987 | Kappa Alpha Theta
Delta Tau Delta |
1987 | Kadee Fabyan
Christopher Courtney | 1992
1988 | Williams Hall
Alpha Chi Omega |
1988 | Bethany (Kinman) Dunlap
Jerre McManama | 1990
1991 | Alpha Phi
Sigma Alpha Epsilon |
1989 | Michelle (Horwath) Beto
Morrie Bunnell | 1990
1990 | Independent–Delta Tau Delta
Delta Tau Delta |
1990 | Pam (Yoder) Eads
Kostas Poulakidas | 1991
1992 | Alpha Phi–Selling Club
Sigma Alpha Epsilon |
1991 | Wendy (Lamberg) Greeley
Eric Ottinger | 1992
1992 | Chi Omega–St.A.R.T.
Delta Tau Delta |
1992 | Lynda Van Davis
Frank Axell | 1993
1993 | Black Student Association
Sigma Nu–Alpha Phi |
1993 | Laura Zimmerman
Michael Schmaltz | 1995
1995 | Sigma Alpha Epsilon
Delta Delta Delta |
1994 | Jennifer (Parks) Stayer
Shawn Butler | 1995
1995 | Alpha Phi
Golden Key |
1995 | Molly (Stoudt) Riggs
Kirk Tebo | 1996
1997 | Alpha Omicron Pi
Sigma Phi Epsilon–Alpha Chi Omega |
1996 | Renate Yssel
Rob Fetzner | 1998
1998 | Student Government Association
Sigma Phi Epsilon |
1997 | Jennifer Tilford
Jason Utesch | 1998
1998 | Alpha Chi Omega–Delta Tau Delta
Theta Chi–Botsford/Swinford |
1998 | Megan Sullivan
Adam Thies | 2000
2000 | Alpha Chi Omega–SLDB
Student Planning Association |
1999 | Shannon O’Dell
Cory Calvin | 2000
2001 | Chi Omega–St.A.R.T.
Sigma Phi Epsilon–SLDB |
2000 | Liz Grau
Tommy Rector | 2002
2002 | Kappa Alpha Theta
Theta Chi–Kappa Alpha Theta |
2001 | Nicole Cervo
Ryan Eddy | 2003
2002 | Woody/Shales Hall Council
Sigma Phi Epsilon |
2002 | Kathy Spenos
Nathan Brown | 2005
2002 | Brayton/Clevenger Hall Council
National Residence Hall Honorary |
2003 | Katie Wiese
Aaron Galvin | 2005
2005 | National Residence Hall Honorary
Botsford/Swinford Halls |
2004 | Sarah Roth
Ben Tietz | 2005
2006 | Schmidt/Wilson Hall Council
Student Government Association |
2005 | Haley DeWees
Matthew Mattmiller | 2006
2006 | Alpha Phi
Sigma Phi Epsilon |
2006 | Rachelle Reichert
Zac Davis | 2008
2008 | Botsford/Swinford Hall
Spectrum |
2007 | Lyndsey Adams
Kyle Johnson | 2010
2008 | Botsford/Swinford Hall
Student Voluntary Services |
2008 | Lauren Madden
Trevor Junga | 2011
2011 | Alpha Phi
University Singers |
2009 | Lauren Petersen
William Garnes | 2011
2012 | Baker/Klipple Hall
Alpha Phi Alpha |
2010 | Morgan Smith
John Towle | 2011
| Chi Omega
Alpha Tau Omega |
2011 | Caitlyn Pohland
Sterlyng Powell | 2013
2012 | Code Red Dance Team
Howick/Williams Hall |
2012 | Caitlyn Cambron
Justin Friend | 2015
2013 | Woody/Shales Hall
Lambda Chi Alpha |
2013 | Amy Yorko
Sidney Staples | 2014
2015 | DeHority Complex
Black Student Association |
2014 | Kayzie Priebe
Wesley Crouch | 2015
2016 | College Mentors for Kids
College Mentors for Kids |
| 2015 | Emma Floit
Jack Hesser | 2016
2016 | Council for Alumni & Student Engagement (CASE)
Lambda Chi Alpha |
2016 | Samantha Johnson
Mitch Prather | 2018
2017 | Delta Zeta
Exercise Science Club |
2017 | Kathy Berryhill
Jacob Germann | 2019
2018 | Residence Hall Association
National Residence Hall Honorary |
2018 | Hanna Crane
Dylan Barrow | 2019
2020
| Ball State University Dance Marathon
Phi Delta Theta |
2019 | Elizabeth Latham
Connor Sanburn | 2020
2021 | Student Government Association
Delta Zeta |
Spring
2021 | Miryam Bevelle
Ceven Webb | 2022
2021
| Student Government Association
Alpha Omicron Pi |
Fall 2021 | Lydia Elliott
Harley Lohmeyer
| 2022
2022 | Alpha Omicron Pi
Sigma Phi Epsilon
|
| 2022 | Jaylyn McDonald
Alex Buxton | 2023
2025 | Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc.
Residence Hall Association |
| 2023 | Monet Lindstrand
Carson Myers | 2024
2025 | Student Government Association
Man 2 Men |