INTRODUCTION & THEMES; RECONSTRUCTION & THE WEST
I. The Relationship Between Laws, Liberty, & The Pursuit of Happiness: The Bill of Rights
         A. Costs & Benefits of Industrialization; Role of Government
         B. Legislating Morality & Putting Faith in Politicians
         C. Civil War’s Legacy: Death, Unity, and Freedom! Justice? Who Won? The Battle Cry of Freedom
II. Reconstruction: social/political conditions for Southern readmission: Link to Sample Documents on Emancipation
        A. Southern Reform: "Black Codes" vs. Congress (Radicals)
                    1. Republican Party's Political Survival/Black Voting vs. A. Johnson
                    2. Amendments 13-15: freedom, citizenry, and suffrage!.
                    3. Tenure of Office Act: Separation of Powers/Checks & Balances
                    4. Johnson Impeached, not Convicted: Link to Various Views, Positive, Official, & Negative (EA)
                    5. Link to Website on Impeachment Process & Narrative of Trial & Debunking the "Hero"
                    6. Why We handle the Internet with Care: Link to Lincoln Assassination Conspiracy Theory Site
       B. Achievement: From Black Codes to "Black Republican" Rule
                    1. "Radical" Takeover: Scalawags, Carpetbaggers, Freedmen
                    2. Public Works Undertaken & Education Expanded: Taxes
 
Illiteracy (%) in South, late 19th century by Race & Age Group
Age Group Age 10-14 Age 15-20 Age 20+
Race/Year 1870 1890 1870 1890 1870 1890
Black  78.9  49.2   85.3  54.1   90.4  75.5
White  33.2  18.7   24.2  14.3   19.8 17.1

                    3. Black Families: Separation, Survival, Sharecropping:
                    4. The Limits of Reconstruction: Segregation Underway
       C. Reconstruction Collapses: Reform Without Prosperity?: Panic of '73
                    1. No Long-term Northern Commitment to Black Equality: Its Consequences
                    2. The Election of 1876 & Compromise of 1877
                                a. Freedom without real Economic Opportunity
                                b. The American Dream, Hypocrisy & S Backwardness
        D. Social & Political Aftermath: Racism & Disfranchisement
                    1. Plessy v. Ferguson, 1896: Separate But Equal Acquires Legal Foundation
                    2. Link to History of NAACP Efforts to Overturn Racial Segregation, 1896-1954
                    3. Response: Booker T. Washington's Cast Down Your Bucket vs. W.E.B. DuBois & NAACP in Opposition
                    4. Link to DuBois' 1903 book, Souls of Black Folk
II. Frontier West: Mining, Cattle, Farming, Transportation Frontiers: Link to PBS Website The West
        A. The Great American Desert & the Leap to the West Coast
        B. Transcontinental RR: Impact of Land Grants
        C. The Indian Frontier: Impact of buffalo extinction
                    1. Resistance and violence
                    2. Sparking Dawes Act Reform: Link to Helen Hunt Jackson’s Century of Dishonor
 
 



INDUSTRIALIZATION: BIG BUSINESS, LABOR, IMMIGRATION & URBANIZATION

1860 1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920
Population 40m 50m 63m 76m 92m 105m
Chicago 300,000 1,500,000
Cars Manufactured 4000  181,000  1,900,000
Average Daily Earnings for
(healthy) workingmen
$1 $1.50 $2
Average Annual Earnings for 
(healthy) workingmen
$300 $425 $550-600
Annual Earnings: 
Agricultural laborer
Clerical Worker
Industrial Worker
Public schoolteacher
233
848
486
256
336
1156
630
492
Railroad Miles 53,000  167,000 

I. Industrialization: Most Vital Agent of US Social & Econ Change Ever?: Characteristics:  What is It?
        A. Technology: Inventions, Applied & Marketed (Bell/Ford/Swift/Armour/Duke/Pillsbury/Edison/ Westinghouse)
        B. Flush Toilet, Tin Can, Kellogg’s Cereal, refrigerated RR car, cigarette roller, Singer's sewing machine
        C. Mass Production concentrated:huge, intricately organized factories w/rigid schedules & repetitive routine—Ford (Link)
        D. Nationwide Transport/Communications = Expanded Markets; Local Urban Expansion
        E. Rising: Population , Immigration, Urbanization, % of Workforce in Manufacturing
II. Industrialization: Who Did It?: Entrepreneurs: Great Captains of Industry? Robber Barons? Link to Discussion of "Robber Barons"
        A. Size/Profits Enable $ for Investment: Democracy Endangered?
                    1. Corporations Limit Individual Loss, Ensure Due Process (14thAmendment)
                    2. Corporate Power: Social Inequality Rises/ $$ Accumulation    
       B.  Andrew Carnegie: Steel King/Rags to Riches Emblem: Harsh Methods, Public Benefactor (Gospel of Wealth)
       C. John D. Rockefeller Seeks Monopoly by Organizing Oil: Vertical & Horizontal Integration
       D. Growth Enables Jobs, BUT Do Workers' Gains Justify Working/Living Conditions? (Link to PBS Website on Carnegie)
       E.  Progress? Balance Costs/Benefits!?! Is US Ideal Rural or Urban? Quality of Life
III. Labor's Compensation & WORKING/LIVING Conditions:   Who Else Did It?
      A. Wages: Real increase: Adequate? See Statistics above
                    1. Overall Inflation 10%,1860-1914 (camouflages ups and downs): $=15x 1990, about 25-30x today
                    2. Minimum need to escape poverty, circa 1910: $466 SF; $505 SM, $800 for family/4
                    3. Women & children in Poverty: Did Women Work Outside the Home? Relevance?
                    4. Child Labor Restrictions? State Laws Evaded;  Bailey v Drexel, 1922   Link to Hine's Child Labor Photographs
IV. Social Costs of Industrialization:   Impact & Consequences:   The Importance of Thrift & Health
     A. Health & safety: death /disability: No workmen's compensation laws before 1911
     B. Link to Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire, 1911
     C. Supreme Court Responses: Holden v Hardy, 1896: limit hrs of dangerous work for miners
     D. Link to Lochner v NY, 1905: can't limit bakers to 60 hrs
     E. Muller v Oregon:  1908: reproductive function vital; sociological relevance applicable
     F. Impersonal and contractual workplace: Transition from custommade to mass-produced (Taylor)
     G. Standards of living/lifestyles improve: tradeoff…companies try to instill good work habits


Piecework at Home: Women & Children at Work
 


Haymarket Affair: Calling Workers to Protest

V. Living Conditions: Can the American City Be Made Livable?: Link to Chicago Fire
        A. Concentrating Production and Markets; Horizontal Expansion/Urban Transportation
        B. Indictment of Living Conditions: Link to  Jacob Riis’ How The Other Half Lives
        C. Politics: Corrupt City Machines & the "Spoils System"
VI. Labor  Responds : Protest: Need for Collective Bargaining & Obstacles to It
       A. Union Types: Craft (American Federation of Labor) & Industrial (Knights/Labor)
                    1. Bosses Resist Unskilled, Ethnically Diverse, Replaceable Workers
                    2. Labor Violence: Public Backlash Against Revolutionaries
                    3. Brief  & Extended Discussion of the Haymarket Affair (1886) & Pullman Strike (1894)
                    4. Government Intervention & Popular Attitudes: Labor’s Limits
       B. Socialism: Not Viable Here: American Dream, Incentive, & Opposition to WW1

IMMIGRATION IN MILLIONS AND BY SOURCES

Era Total Britain Ireland Germany Scandinavia Italy East & Central Europe Russia
1840-1860  4.2 0.7 1.7 1.4  --  --  --  --
1860-1880  4.8 1.1 0.9 1.5 0.3 0.05 0.07 0.04
1880-1900  8.9 1.1 1.1 2.0 1.1 0.9 1.0 0.6
1900-1925  17.3 1.1 0.6 0.7 0.8 3.6 3.9 2.7

VII. Who Were They?: Labor Personnel: The "New Immigration"
       A. Who is an American? Evaluate Response to New Entrants
       B. Changing Composition: N & W Europe Before 1890, S & E Europe After 1890
                    1. Religion/Ethnicity/Language/Culture
                    2. Responses: Temperance, Prohibition, Schools
                    3. What Defines an American: Race? Creed? Dream? Adherence to Rule of Law/Constitution?
VIII. Industrialization & Foreign Relations Background:    Washington's FAREWELL
        A. Basic Goals & Principles: Security, Trade, Morality, Public Consent
        B. Independence & Hemispheric Priority & West Conquest
                    1. What is Isolationism: Contact W/o Commitment, Hemispheric Priority
                    2. Superior Morality: City Upon A Hill (Anti-Imperialism)
                    3. Reasons & Context for the Monroe Doctrine, 1823
                    4. Yet  Freedom of Commerce:  Open Door: Markets & RM Access (China)
                    5. Isolation, Trade, & Moral Detachment Possible Amid Change?
        C. In sum: LEAVE US ALONE, LEAVE THEM BE, LET US IN, AND REMEMBER WE'RE MORALLY AND MATERIALLY SUPERIOR.
IX. Industrialization & Foreign Relations: Evolving Imperialism
       A. From Manifest Destiny/Postwar Recovery to Pacific & Caribbean
       B. Toward Hemispheric Dominance: War, TR, & the Canal


Cartoon Seeking Action in Cuba

                    1. Splendid Little War with Spain: Weyler's "reconcentrado"
                    2. Yellow Journalism: Hearst vs. Pulitzer: Public Anger
                    3. Why did We Fight: Remembering the Maine?
                    4. Imperialism Wise? Spoils of Victory: Manila! Havana? Link to anti-imperialist Cartoons
                    5. McKinley’s Reasons for Annexing the Philippines & Beveridge's March of the Flag
                    6.  Panama Canal: Bullying Brits/Colombians, Hay-Pauncefote/Hay-Herran
                    7.  Roosevelt Corollary: Improving Upon & Enforcing Monroe

Cartoon Justifying U.S. Imperialism
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

GILDED AGE POLITICS AND THE AGRARIANS' & PROGRESSIVES' CHALLENGES

I. What Do Politicians Want & What Do We Want From Them?
       A. Do They Seek Reform? Should They?
       B.  Can They Legislate Morality: What Kind? Whose?
       C. Did They respond to Industrialization’s Impact on Farmers?
II. Stability: Balance of Power Between Congress & Weak Presidency
       A. Power Bases of Competing Republican & Democratic Coalitions
                    1. Era of Political Deadlock/Stalemate, 1874-1892
                    2. REP: "party of moral purposes" (N, $, veterans, rural)
                    3. DEM: "party of personal liberties" (S, N Urban, RC)
        B. Vital Issues & Campaigns: Economic Vs Cultural Coalitions
                    1. Civil War: "Bloody Shirt" and Veterans Pensions
                    2. Prosperity (Sectional v National): Republicans Win on Tariffs
                    3. Good Govt: Civil Service Reform of "Spoils System": Pendleton Act
                    4. Who Gets Govt Jobs? Why? Connections? Merit?: Arthur's Response
                    5. Campaign '84: Blaine/Cleveland: "Party of Rum, Romanism & Rebellion
                    6. Campaign '88: Harrison/Cleveland: The "Murchison Letter"
                    7. Monetary Policy: Farmers And Westerners Complain
        C. Political Finance, Corruption, High Voter Turnout: BUSINESS Triumphs!

III. Realignment: Farmers Revolt vs. Cultural/Econ Exclusion: Can/Should Their Livelihood Be Protected?
        A. A Rural Response to Costs of Industrialization: Cultural Victims: Link to Description of Isolation
        B. Pre-Civil War: Foundation of Democracy, Now "Hick" Behind Industrial Times
        C. Political Realignment Triggered by ‘93 Depression & Collapse in Farm Prices
                    1. Wheat $/bushel from 1.20 in 1870 to .50 in '94; Cotton $/lb.  10.50 in 1882 to under $5, '94; Corn $/bushel .63 in 1881 to .28 in 1896
                    2. Anger at Railroads re Transport Costs
                    3. Farmer Anger at Tariff Rates: N Industry vs. S&W Agriculture
                    4. Monetary Policy: "The Crime of '73" & Conspiracy Theory
                                a. Why is Monetary Policy Significant?
                                b. Economic Growth & Currency Stagnation
                                c. Who Likes Inflation? Debtors
                                d. Bland-Allison ('78) & Sherman Silver Purchase Act 1890
                                e. Cleveland's Response: Business Confidence Requires Sherman Act Repeal, 1893
                                f. Balanced Overall Assessment of Cleveland’s Presidency: Link
        D. Depression's Effect on Congress: Democrats Lose 113 Seats, 1894
        E. Voices of Rural Protest Organized: Farmers' Alliance Reinvents Self as Populist Party
        F. Platform points:
                    1. Sub-Treasury plan: gov't assistance (1933)
                    2. silver coinage (never)
                    3. tighter regulation of RR & end to tariffs (1903, 1913)
                    4. federal, graduated income tax (1913)
                    5. direct election of senators on secret ballot (1913)
       G. Populist Party: People's Democracy Absorbed by Democrats
       H. William Jennings Bryan: The "Cross of Gold" & 1896 Election: Cross of Gold Speech & White's Opposition
        I.  Silver & An Allegory of a Wizard; Limits of Agrarian Dissent
        J. Link to Recent Analysis of Farm Subsidies
 

IV. Progressivism: An Urban Response to Industrialization
       A. Goals: Corporate Regulation, Social Justice, Democracy, Efficiency
       B. Beyond Individualism: Attack Abuses of Power & Get Good Government
       C. Scientific Efficiency: Manage Business/Government Co-operation
       D. Why Seek Change? How Know Which Way to Go?
                    1. Confidence In Elite Selves: Lead & Educate Inferiors
                    2. Hope/Belief in People's Goodness & Fear of Revolt
                    3. Belief in People, Need Government to Act For Them
       E. Complex Intellectual Context: Social Darwinism
                    1. Scientific Spirit vs. Determinism vs. Optimistic Outrage
                    2. Herbert Spencer: "survival of the fittest"
                                a. Justification for Big Business & Foreign Activity
                                b. But, Reform Darwinism: the Growing Determination to Act
                    3. Activist Response: Protestant Social Gospel
                    4. Optimistic Aid for Evolution: Priority for Body Over Soul
        F. Ideas & Law: Pragmatism: William James: ends justify means
                    1. Law/Truth: Immutable or Evolving Tool for Social Change?
                    2. Be Righteous or Pragmatic? Seek Good or Freedom? How Define & Apply Truth to Laws & Society?
                    3. Can Govt or Individuals Affect Human Nature/Behavior?
       G. Agents: Muckrakers Sinclair, Steffens & Tarbell (Link to Her Lengthy Condemnation of Standard Oil)
V. Progressive Political Order Moves Toward? Democracy
       A. Democracy vs Efficiency & Professionalism
       B. Secret Ballots, Primaries, Initiative, Referendum, Recall
       C. Choosing Candidates, Petitions & Express Opinion
       D. Women in Politics: Temperance, Prohibition, & Suffrage
       E. Changing Rules: Southern Suffrage Restricted
                    1. Populists: Racist Effect of 1890s Political Realignment
                    2. Blacks Disfranchised By Residency, Tax, Literacy, Grandfather Clause
       F. Urban Hope: Immigrants Want Safer Factories/Housing
       G. Urban Conflict: Prohibition/Civil Service Reform vs. Immigrants
VI. Party Politics in the Progressive Era
       A. Republican Accomplishments (Ducking Tariffs & All-out Trustbusting)
                    1. TR: Elkins & Hepburn Acts (RR), FDA, Conservation
                    2. Essay on Roosevelt the Environmentalist: Link
       B. Campaign & Election, 1912: New Freedom vs. New Nationalism
       C. Wilson & Democrats: Tariff Reform: The Underwood Tariff
                    1. The Federal Reserve System & Corporate Regulation
                   2. Labor and Farm Assistance
VII. Progressives' Ideological Legacy: New View of Govt & People
       A. Active Government: The Path to the New Deal & Great Society
       B. Paternalism vs Optimism: Contradictions of Change
       C. Also Evident in Foreign Relations: See Roosevelt Corollary
       D. Coercion & Freedom: Toward Prohibition: A Mixed Legacy
       E. Margaret Sanger & Origins of Planned Parenthood: See Eugenics Photo Below & Links to Pro & Con 1  & Con 2 Views
       F. Link to Scholarly Examination of Eugenics Movement

 

WORLD WAR I: AMERICAN "NEUTRALITY"
I. WW1: Europe's Suicide and Stalemate: Why Important?
        A. Origins Inspire Quest to Avoid War: German Problem, Arms Races, Economic Competition, Secret Alliances, & the Last Straw
        B. Conduct Inspires Quest to Avoid War: Senseless Slaughter
                    1. Dehumanization of Participants: Value of Civilian Life
                    2. Liberal Optimism and Hope for Progress & Social/Economic Change Damaged
        C. Trench Warfare Stalemate: Seeking Decision through Allies
II. The First World War: American Power and America's Role
        A. American Benevolent Neutrality & Its Flaws: Truly Neutral?
        B. Will "Hyphenated Americans" Cause Rifts? Stay Neutral!
        C. Economic Imperatives: Geography, Blockade & Trade Patterns
                    1. Exports to Britain & France $754m 1914; $3 billion in 1916
                    2. Exports to Germany $345m 1914; $29 million in 1916
                    3. Merchant/Customer Interdependence: Enmeshed!
                    4. Cultural Ties, Loans to the Allies & The Drift toward Unneutrality
        D. European Challenges to American Neutrality
                    1. British Violations: Confiscating Property, Redefining Contraband & Imposing Illegal Blockade
                    2. German Practice: Killing: Lusitania Incident (5/7/15)
        E. USA Quest to Avoid War Amid British & German Aggravations
                    1. British Alienate USA: Easter Rebellion & Blacklist
                    2. But Recognize Mutual $ Dependence on USA & Vice-Versa
                    3. 1916 Election Intervenes: He Kept Us Out of War!
                    4. Germans Refuse to Acknowledge American Interests
III. U.S. Entry into World War I: From Mediation to War
        A. Wilson: Peace without Victory? January 1917
        B. Germany: Unrestricted Submarine Warfare: US Breaks Relations
                    1. Germans: We Can Starve Brits Out in Six Months
                    2. Germans: US Army Won't Be Ready For At Least A Year
   C. Link to Zimmerman Telegram: Possible Threat to Hemisphere (?)
   D. Wilson Waits, But US Ships Sunk
   E. Russian Revolution: Irony for Germans & A Democratic Friend
   F. Primary Reasons For Belligerency: Moral & Economic; Security?
               1. Definition of Vital & Moral Interests: the U-Boat
               2. Industrialization: Economic Strength, Vulnerability, & Interdependence
               3. A Later Generation's Skepticism: The Nye Committee
   G. The Terms of Entry As Expressed by Wilson, April 1917: A War to End All Wars
                    1. Request for Declaration of War (Link): A Crusade to Make the World Safe for Democracy
                    2. An "Associated Power," Not an Ally
   H. Euro Independence Ends: TransAtlantic Interdependence

US Propaganda: Depiction of Women               US Propaganda: Depiction of Germans

VICTORY & RETREAT: INTERVENTION & THE VERSAILLES TREATY BATTLE

I. American Participation in the War to End All Wars
   A. The Home Front: Preparing An Army, An Economy, & A People
              1. Mobilize AEF: "Selective Service" Locally Administered
              2. Industrial Mobilization for Total War: Gov't Runs RR
              3. Social Impact: Prosperity, Migration, New Opportunity
                   4. Emotional Mobilization and Civil Liberties
                           a. George Creel & Committee for Public Information (Link)
                           b. "Expression, not Repression": The Four-Minute Men
                           c. War Hysteria: "liberty" cabbage, measles, & pups
                           d. War & Progressivism: Its Limits: Schenck v. U.S.
                           e. Morality & Wartime Patriotism: The 18th Amendment
         B. Military Contributions: "The Decisive Power"
    C. Economic/Financial Assistance: From Debtor to Creditor: The Lingering War Debt Issue
    D. Victory: The Fourteen Points & Collapse of Central Powers
II. The Fourteen Points (Link): Wilson's Peace Plan to End WW1
    A. Open World: no secret alliances, arms cuts, freedom of seas
    B. Self-Determination (for Europeans, not colonials/Nonwhites)
    C. League of Nations: mutual enforcement mechanism

US Propaganda: Fight for Freedom                      US Propaganda: Conserve & Produce

III. Peace Conference: Evaluating Versailles Treaty: Link to Text
     A. Unwise Partisan Oct. 1918 appeal: Ineffective: Rep. Senate
     B. US Delegation: Wilson Will Go: Unprecedented! Indispensable?
     C. Ineffective Compromise of Self-Determination: Germans & US Public Unhappy
             1. Neither a Victor's Peace Nor a Peace of Accommodation
             2. Did Germany Lose? A Stab in the Back: Betrayal
     D. Status Quo Possible w/o Americans?: League Integral
IV.  Reasons for Opposition to & Defeat of Versailles Treaty
     A. Senate Defends Its Prerogatives
            1. Advice & Consent on Treaties (2/3) & Congress' Privilege to Declare War
            2. Article X: collective security versus U.S. Sovereignty?
            3. mutual guarantee of political independence and territorial integrity to all
     B. Lodge-Wilson Feud: The Role of Personal Enmity
     C. WW Tours Country: Stroke & Near-Death: Won't Compromise
     D. The Senate Splits: Reservationists & Irreconcilables (The Role of  "Isolationist" Tradition)
     E. Wilson's Illness, Refusal to Compromise, & His Legacies: Link to Assessments & More Positive View
 
 

    THE ROARING TWENTIES: INTELLECTUAL, CULTURAL & POLITICAL CONFLICT

I. HOW DO WORLD WARS AFFECT US At Time & Afterward?
    A. Personal & Political: Casualties, Dehumanization & Isolationism
    B. The Price of Freedom
    C. Economic: From Boom to Bust & Depression & New Deal to War & Recovery
    D. Social Change: Women & Minorities, Nativism
    E. Intellectual: Liberal Optimism about Progress Gives Way to Relativism
            1. Why Are We Here & Where Are We Going?
            2. Premodernism, Modernism, & Postmodernism
                    a. Powerful Ideas Suggest that Rational Humans Not Master of Destiny
                    b. Religious Faith vs Rational Science vs Irrational Humanity?
                    c. Darwin, Marx & Freud: Origins, Economics & Sex
                    d. Einstein's Theory of Relativity & Heisenberg's Principle of Uncertainty
                    e. Link to T.S. Eliot’s  poem The Hollow Men & Yeats' Second Coming
            3. Relativism: Who Decides Authority & Truth?
II. America on the Defensive: Responses to New Ideas
    A. Transition to Peace Amid Haphazard Economic Demobilization

    B. The Pursuit of Pleasure and the Fascination with Celebrity & Technology: Sports Heroes, Action Heroes: Ruth, Lindbergh, Garvey
    C. Fear & The Red Scare: Strikes, Bombings, Riots, and the Bolsheviks
                 1. Atty. General A. Mitchell Palmer's Response &  Impact of Crusades and Scares: Disillusionment & Fear
    D. Nativism: Hatred of Radicals & Immigrants
                1. Sacco & Vanzetti Case
                2. The Emergency Immigration Act of 1921 (& 1924) & No Reapportionment of Congressional Districts
                3. "100% Americanism": The Ku Klux Klan in Indiana: Why?
    E. Fundamentalism's Five Points vs. Faith in Science: (Link for) The Scopes Trial: Publicity for Evolution (Bryan v. Darrow)
    F. Sports, Sex, Flappers, the 1920s... & The Typical Town?: Robert & Helen Lynd's Examination
    G.  Prohibition: A Noble, Ineffective Experiment?  Link to Anti-Saloon League Activists
                1. Enforcement, Bootlegging, Organized Crime; Technology, Mobility & Firepower
                2. What Should Be the Government's Role in Encouraging "Responsible" Behavior?: Today's Question of Cigarettes
III. Politics: Normalcy: The Harding-Coolidge Years (1921-29): Good & Bad Appointments: Reliance on Subordinates
        A. Teapot Dome Scandal & Harding's Death
                1. Secretary of the Interior Albert Fall Tries to Recoup Mexican Loss
                2. Drilling for Navy Oil without Competitive Bidding: Kickbacks
        B. Coolidge Profits from 1924 Democratic National Convention--Coolidge on Republican Principles (Audio)
                1. Deep Democratic Divisions: KKK & Prohibition
                2. Protecting Local Folkways: Saloon & Segregation
                3. Will Rogers: "I belong to no organized political party. I am a Democrat."
                4. Business Boom Bolsters Republican Ascendancy: Conservative Tribute to Coolidge Coolidge’s Personality (Link)
 

Economic Growth Statistics, 1920's
GNP  Consumer Debt Cars Registered Refrigerators
1920  $ 3,000,000,000  8,000,000 2500
1922  $70,000,000,000 
1929  $100,000,000,000 $ 8,000,000,000  23,000,000 500,000
ECONOMIC BOOM & DISASTER: HOOVER & THE GREAT DEPRESSION I. Business Boom: Leading Sectors, Govt. Policy & Roots of Depression
       A. Consumer Goods & Electricity: Labor-Saving Appliances
       B. Technology's Impact on Women's Lives: Easier?
       C. Republican Domestic Economic Policy: Laissez Faire
                     1. Cut Spending, Balance Budgets, Lax Regulation
                     2. Tax Cuts Favor Rich, But How Spend It? Invest! In What?
                     3. Can Workers Afford Products of Techno Innovations?: Low Purchasing Power: Wages, Taxes & Tariffs
                                       a. Installment Plan Buying: Only Way to Buy Durable Goods
                                       b. Surpluses Result from Wage/Productivity Imbalance
                                       c. Balance Responsibility & Freedom? Owner & Workers
       D. Other Question Marks in Business Boom
                     1. Agriculture: McNary-Haugen Bill: Coolidge veto
                     2. Stock Market: The Bull Market: "Buying on Margin"
                     3. Labor Relations & Tariff Policy
                     4. Foreign Economic Policy: Counterproductive Nationalism: Cancel or Collect Allied War Debts?
                                      a. Global Context: Smoot-Hawley Tariff (1930)
                                      b. Retaliation: Foreign Trade Collapses: $9.6 bn 1929 to $2.9 bn, 1932
       E. Crash & Great Depression: Causes & Consequences
       F. Results: Unemployment From 3% to 30% & Income Cut in Half
II. Hoover Acts: Seek Confidence: Limited Moves Beyond Laissez-Faire
        A. Mellon: Liquidate everything & everyone versus Hoover: Maintain Wage Rates through Voluntarism
        B. Links: Partisan Pro-Hoover (Brief) and (Thorough) Hoover Library Version & Blurb for Hoover Bio
        C. Increasing Purchasing Power: Help for Individuals?
                       1. Spending On Public Works, Tax Cuts, Farm Loans But Tax Increase to Balance Budget!
                       2. Reconstruction Finance Corporation: Trickle-Down
III. Public Discontent & Long-Term Consequences
       A. Farmers' Plight: Prices Down 80-90% Since 1919
       B. Social Disruption: Letters from Americans to the President
       C. Images of Poverty: Link to The Farm Security Administration Photos
       D. Hoovervilles & Political Defeat for Republicans
                       1. Vets' Anger: "Bonus Expeditionary Force"; GI Bill Next Time Around
                       2. Hoover's Failure Was Leadership; Democrats Resurge with FDR
                       3. The Destruction of Dreams: Middle-Class Quest for Order
                                           a. 30's Deprivation, Fifties Materialism, Sixties Revolt
                                           b. Context For Our Cultural Divisions: What is Good Life?
                                           c. Is Order or Liberty More Important? Can We Have Both?
                       4. What is Government's Role In Economic Crisis?
IV. The 1932 Campaign: FDR: A "New Deal for the American People"
       A. Few Substantive Disagreements with Hoover
       B. Radical Alternatives Disdained: CP and Soc=2.3% Vote
       C. Attitude: Recovery from Polio: Confidence and Victory
       D. Link to FDR Political Cartoon Archive: Link to Health Cartoon 1 & 2
       E. Link to Biographical Sketch of Roosevelt:  Experimentation & Improvisation Are Key
        F. The Interregnum of Despair: The Banking Panic
        G. Inaugural Address: The Only Thing We Have to Fear is Fear Itself
 
 

FDR & THE GREAT DEPRESSION

I. DID THE NEW DEAL CONQUER THE GREAT DEPRESSION?  Psychologically? Economically?
II. FDR: Happy Days Are Here Again: The New Deal's Three R's
              A. The Hundred Days: Roosevelt's New Start for America  ( Link to List of Alphabet Soup Programs)
              B. Restore Confidence: Reopened Banks Amid Emergency: Deposits Safe
              C. Bank Reform: Glass-Steagall Act: FDIC Insures Deposits
                              1. FCA/HOLC: Refinancing Rural & Urban Mortgages: Link to Help Cartoon 1&2
              D. Local to Federal Work Relief for Distressed Individuals: DOLE?
                              1. CCC: Work Relief for Young Men (Discipline/Conservation)
              E. Regulation: On Toward Long-Term Recovery through Planning
                              1. AGRICULTURE:  Lack of Faith in the Free Market: Can Farms Recover?
                                        a. AAA: Compensate Farmers for Fallow Land: Sharecroppers Become Okies
                                        b. CCC: Loan $ to Farmers To Delay Crops on Market
                              2.  INDUSTRIAL  Recovery (NIRA: NRA & PWA): Prime the Pump
                                        a. PWA: Planned Permanent Improvements: Ickes
                                        b. NRA: Mgmt/Labor/Govt Co-operate, Aids (?) Recovery
                                              i.  Codify Fair Practices & Generate Purchasing Power, But Clumsy Controls & Intrusions: Growth?
                                              ii. Clause 7(a): Labor's Right to Organize, but NIRA Unconstitutional: Schechter vs US
                                        c. Landmarks Endure: 40Hr Work Week, Child Labor, Minimum Wage
III. The "Second New Deal": From Unity to Helping the Underdog
              A. Congressional Elections, 1934: Democrats' Rare Increase in Seats
              B.  Desperation & Demagoguery: Huey Long: "Share Our Wealth" : Link to his summary of his program
              C. Wagner Act/NLRB: Labor's Right to Organize & Bargain Collectively Saved
              D. Social Security: The New Deal's "Supreme Achievement"
                              1. Retirees' Pensions, Unemployment, Aid to Dependent & Disabled
                              2.  Icon of Stability, Yet A Sacred Cow
                              3. Impedes Recovery: Regressive v Progressive Taxation
             E. Is Soaking the Rich Effective? 75% Tax over $5m
             F. More Work Relief & Public Works: Hopkins' WPA Creates 10m Jobs
                              1. Avoids The Dole: "Narcotic, Subtle Destroyer..."
                              2. Complaints About Lazy Workers & Subsidy for Arts
                              3. Modern Funding for Culture: NEA: Link to Arguments in Favor and Against
IV. The Election of 1936: Forming the New Deal Coalition
              A.  Rich & Businessmen Oppose: Principle & Power, Managed Wealth
              B.  Support: Ag, Eth, Middle, Labor, & Blacks: Genuine Love for FDR
              C.  Union Growth: 1933: 2.8m; 1940: 8.9m; 1945: 14.8m
V. FDR's 2nd Term: New Deal Sputters...Checks/Balances Threatened by Packing the Court? FDR's Case & Opposition & More Opposition
             A.  Supreme Court "Provocation": Schechter vs US
             B.  Losing the Battle But Winning the War?: Links to Critical View & Cartoons 1,2,3,4, 5
             C.  Southern Opposition Grows: Coalition with Republicans to 60's
                              1. A Dictator? Ending 2/3 DNC Rule, Attempted Purge of S Dems, 1938; Exec Branch Reorganization Fails
             D. Renewed Depression in 1937: A Sharp Downturn: VICTORY??
                              1. The Role of Government Spending: Prime the Pump with countercyclical Keynesianism?: deficit spending
                              2. Not Fully Tried in New Deal: See WW2 Spending
VI. New Deal Legacy: Government's New Duty to Ensure Individual Economic & Social Stability
             A. Providing a Safety Net: FDIC and Social Security
             B. Reforming Capitalism: Experimentation, not Radicalism
             C. New Deal Positives: Bank Reform, Relief, Psych Hope vs Negatives: Tax, Ag & Industrial Policy
 
 

"ISOLATIONISM"

I. US Foreign Policy Between the World Wars: Impact of WW1
                A. Were We Really Isolationist? Sentiment & Reality
                        1. Political Freedom of Action Re Europe, Reject League
                        2. Domestic Opinion, Self-Delusion & Impact on Policy
                B. Seeking Peace: Reject League, Seek Disarmament, Outlaw War
                        1. Washington Conference & Its Consequences, 1921
                                 a. 5:5:3 Ratio & 10-Year Building Moratorium
                                 b. No Forward Bases: Must Keep Japan as Friend
                        2. Prejudice and Policy: 1924 Immigration Act
                        3. The Kellogg-Briand Pact: Illusion of Perpetual Peace: (Link to Text) of Pact
                C. Caribbean: Ensure Stability & Profits
                        1. Shift From TR Corollary to National Guards & Dictators
                        2. Kinder, Gentler Hegemony: Good Neighbor Policy
                D. Europe: War Debts Controversy Intensifies Sentiment
                        1. "They Hired the Money!" Cancel or Collect Allied War Debts?
                        2. How Can They Pay?: Fordney-McCumber Tariff, 1922
                        3. Dawes & Young Plans (1924 & 1929) for War Debts & German Reparations
                        4. Short-Term Foreign Loans Called Home Thanks to Depression
                        5. Hoover's Moratorium Fails; Mutual Bitterness Contributes to "Isolationism"
                        6. Johnson Debt Default Act (1934)
II.  Aggressors March: Japan Attacks China, Germany Threatens Europe
                A. Japan: Demography, Geography, Economics & Expansion
                        1. Why Care?: Applying the Open Door, 1899: Its Goals
                                a. equal commercial opportunity
                                b. Territorial integrity of China
                                c. Motivations: Missionaries, Market, Model
                       2. A Long Ago Bluff Is Now Called: USA Stands Alone
                       3. US Response to Japanese Aggression: Stimson Doctrine
               B. Ideological Struggle in Europe: Capitalism, Communism & Fascism
               C. Germany: Rise of Hitler: Hostility & Capability United
                        1. Hate, Depression, Rearming: Remilitarize Rhineland '36
                        2. His Program: Anschluss & SUDETENS '38, Poland '39
                        3. Munich 9/38: British & French "Cowardly" Appeasement
                        4. War Begins: Hitler Conquers France & Europe '40-41
                        5. Is European Chaos a Threat to the United States?
III. US Response to Looming Danger: Memories of WW1 & Neutrality
                A. Revisionist Historians & Nye Committee: "Merchants of Death"
                B. Neutrality Acts: Keeping the USA out of World War One!?!  1935-37: No arms sales; no travel on belligerent ships
                C. The Panay Incident Reinforces Animosity toward Japan, but..
                D. The Ludlow Amendment Illustrates Power of Isolationism
                E. Alternative Lessons of History: Munich & Appeasement
                         1. Munich: British & French "Cowardice"
                         2. WW1, Fay & Nye: No War is Worth Fighting!
                         3. THE MUNICH ANALOGY: Aggressors Must Be Stopped!
                        4. The Danger of Believing History Repeats Itself Exactly
 
 


FROM "ISOLATIONISM" TO INTERVENTION: THE WAR IN EUROPE

I. US Response to War: Redefining Nat'l Security Slowly, 1939-1941
               A. Phony War to Blitzkrieg: Fall of Fr 6/40: German Threat to US?
               B. Rivals' Great Debate: Internationalists v Isolationists
                       1. Br Need Ships, $$, Goods...Troops? Will Aid Risk War?
                       2. "Committee to Defend America by Aiding the Allies"
                       3. "America First Committee": Stay Out & Nazis No Threat: Link to Lindbergh's Isolationist Argument (Audio)
               C. WHY Help Appeasers?: WSC, Dunkirk, Oran, Battle of Britain
                       1. Churchill’s Stirring Rhetoric: Link to excerpt from "Never Surrender" Speech & Link to "Finest Hour Speech" (see last para) (audio)
                       2. HOW?: Hemispheric Defense: the Destroyers/Bases Deal
                       3. WHEN: What Can Be Done During 1940 Campaign?
                       4. Devious Lend-Lease 12/40-3/41: Eliminating the $$ Sign
                                  a.  "Act to Promote the Defense of the United States"
                                  b. Arsenal of Democracy: NEUTRAL AT ALL? ISOLATED?? Link to Expression of Our Goals: 4 Freedoms
               D. Edging toward War in the Atlantic and Pacific
                       1. Convoy to Iceland & Shoot on Sight While Japan Seeks Resources: Aggression
                                  a. The Tripartite Pact (Sept 1940) Sets Tone; Japan's Move into Indochina and US Response
                                  b. Appeasement Impossible: The Legacy of Munich
                                  c. Opportunism Sparked ATTACK Plan Before Sanctions
               E. Debate Resolved: Pearl Harbor 12/41 A Back Door to War? NO!
                       1. US Failure: Codebreaking and Interpreting Intelligence
                       2. Japanese Success and Failure
                       3. Link to Roosevelt’s Speech Asking for a Declaration of War    (& Link to Audio)
II. The Course of Battle: Early Struggles
               A. The Meaning of the Doolittle Raid: Background for Midway
               B. Halting the Japanese & Buying Time: Midway & Guadalcanal
               C. Losing The Battle of the Atlantic?, 1941-1942
III. War in Europe: The Anglo-American Alliance: Germany First
               A. Strategy: Win The Battle of the Atlantic ('43) & Aid USSR
               B. Br Radar & Codebreaking & US Merchant Shipbuilding Win Atlantic Battle
              C. The Second Front: How Help Russia? When? Where? Round I, '42
                      1. USSR Wants Anglo-American Invasion of France NOW!
                      2. The British Way Versus The American Way of War
                      3. Temporary British triumph: TORCH & Its Aftermath
                                 a. FDR Overrules JCS to Attack North Africa, 11/42
                                 b. Unconditional Surrender of Germany & Japan Sought 1/43: Text Link
                                 c. Political Context: "Darlan Deal" & "Dolchstosslegende"
               D. US Response to the Holocaust of 5-6m Jews; Link to Himmler’s Rationale
               E. "Round the Clock" Strategic Bombing: Area Bombing
                      1. Army Air Corps Belief: We Can Win It Alone
                      2. From Pinpoint to Area Bombing: Technology & Morality
                      3. Interdiction to Support Troops: Precursor to D-Day
               F. The Second Front: Round II, 1943-1944: The triumph of American power over British: OVERLORD
                      1. "Real" Second Front Delayed: Sicily & Italy
                      2.  D-Day 6/6/44: Deception, Interdiction, Industry, Infantry, & Ike
IV. On to Berlin & V-E Day 5/45: Germany Collapses, A New War Begins
               A. The Breakthrough Sputters: A Bridge Too Far
               B. From the Battle of the Bulge to the Bridge at Remagen
               C. World War 2 & the Cold War: 2nd Front, Katyn, & Warsaw
  WAR AND SOCIETY, 1941-1945: THE HOME FRONT & THE PACIFIC WAR
Wartime Economic Statistics
Year Govt Income
($ bn) 
Govt Spending ($ bn) Military Spending ($bn) Taxpayers (mn) Civilian
Workers (mn)
 Armed Forces (mn)
1940 6.9 9.6 1.8 14.6  47.5   0.5
1941 9.2  14 6.3 25.8 50.3   1.8
1942 15 34  23  36.5 53.7   3.9
1943 25 79  63  43.5  54.5   9.0
1944 48 94  76  47.1 54.0  11.5

I. Military & Economic Mobilization: Conversion for Total War
                  A. The Arsenal of Democracy: Convert Factories, Fill Surplus Capacity (JOBS!): Synthetic Rubber, Shipbuilding
                  B. Financing the War: Taxation & War Bonds: Increased, Deficit Spending: "Proving" Keynes Right
                                 1. Tax Burden Spread to Lower Income Brackets, But Income Redistribution: Impact on Wealth Extremes
                                2. Pay As You Go Tax Withholding
II. Migration & Social Change: Don't You Know There's A War On?
               A. Women's Roles in the Workplace & Military:  The Janes Who Make the Planes & Rosie the Riveter
                                1. Still only 1/3 Adult Married Women Work Outside Home
               B. Blacks: A. Philip Randolph vs Job Discrimination: EO 8802
                                1. Segregation & the "Double V": Opposing Hitler & Hitlerism
                                2. Link to the Political Dr. Seuss and Cartoon Images
               C. Navajo Code-Talkers Contribute in Pacific Theater
               D. Japanese-Americans' Plight: Executive Order 9066: Link to Text & Overview with Documents & Constitutional/Legal Context & Images
                                 1.  Link to Text of Supreme Court Ruling that Upheld Relocation (Korematsu v US, 1944): See Murphy's Dissent
                                 2.  The Exception to An Improved Record on Civil Liberties
                                 3.  Nisei Relocation & Wartime Heroics of 442nd RCT

           E. Mobilizing Attitudes: Rationing Resources & Restraining Freedom for Everyone

III. An American War: The Pacific War
               A. Leapfrogging Rabaul & Truk Reduces Casualties;  Two-Pronged Attack Due to Interservice Rivalry
               B. Conduct of the War & Its Impact: War Dehumanizes People
                            1. Cultural Differences, POW Death March, Race, Kamikazes
                            2. Island Battles for Air Bases: Iwo Jima & Okinawa
                            3. Unrestricted Sub War: Interdiction: Starving Japan & Incinerating It with Incendiary Bombing
                           4. The Potsdam Declaration: Surrender or Else!
               C. Ending War: Manhattan Project: Should We have Dropped It? Scholar Argues Yes; A Recent Editorial; & Link to Opposing view
IV. How Did Depression & War Change America & Americans?


Going Ashore on D-Day
 
 

Depiction of Bataan Death March

Propaganda for Motivation: Why Fight? (above and below)


Promoting Good Relations with Allies

Women in the War Effort                                     Propaganda for Conservation

  Propaganda for Food Production

                War Bonds Motivation                                     Fear of Espionage

 

 
 

THE ORIGINS & EARLY COURSE OF THE COLD WAR: CONTAINMENT TO VIETNAM

I. Cold War: Dominant Characteristics of Soviet-American Conflict: Links to Popular Site & Scholarly Site
    A. Why Did They Conflict? Is Soviet Threat Real?
             1. Antagonistic IDEOLOGIES: World Revolution vs Democracy
             2. Cyclical SuperPOWER Conflict: Confrontation & Deténte
    B. USA Desire: Prevent Hostile World: Ideology, Econ, Strategic
             1. Where Preserve Freedom, How Do So? Why Korea? Vietnam?
             2. Filling Power Vacuums: Central Europe & East Asia
             3. Limits on Where: How Far Do We Go? Everywhere? Particularism vs Universalism
                    a. Criteria: Military-Industrial Power: Save Some?
                    b. Criteria: Moral/Psych/Credibility: Save All?
   C. Who Started the Cold War? Who Won It?
II. Origins of the Cold War: Issues: E. Europe, Atoms, & GERMANY
    A. Early Problems: FDR's Legacy and Truman's Inexperience
              1. Could USSR have Friendly, Free Eastern European Neighbors?
                    a. USA Voters: Chicago; Democratic Power Bases in Cities
                    b. POLISH Memories: Katyn Forest & Warsaw Massacres
              2. Atomic Energy: The Baruch Plan & Verification
              3. Threats to Greece & Turkey... & .....
    B. Diagnosis & Remedy: Kennan's "Long Telegram": Containment: Link to Text of Long Telegram & "Sources of Soviet Conduct"-see end of Part II
             1. Russian Nationalism And Communist World Takeover?
             2. New Course: Scaring American People: Truman Doctrine
             3. Link to Doctrine Text: "to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or outside pressures"
             4. Public Assumptions About USSR Coalesce: "Red Fascism": Global Revolution, Hostile Totalitarian Atheist Monolithic Communism
    C. Chaos Causes Communism: Economic Stability for Europe?
              1. Marshall Plan, June 1947: Economic Response
              2. "directed not against country or doctrine, but against hunger, poverty, desperation, & chaos"
              3. Requirements: Common Plan, Open Books, Buy US Goods
              4. Passage, 1948: Coup in Prague Affects Congress
    D. Reunite/Rebuild A Divided Germany? Trizonia: Econ Unity
               1. British, French, US Zones Reunited with Broken Promise
               2. Berlin Blockade Leads to Berlin Airlift Leads to NATO
               3. NATO: Entangling Alliance: USSR Out, Germans Down, USA In: Link to Treaty Text (1949)
    E. Containment's Pitfalls:  Success in Europe: Viable in Asia? (Universalism)
                    1. Reliance On Wobbly & Manipulative Allies/Clients, on Military & Nukes

                    2. Impatience & Limited Wars: Real Victory Possible?
                    3. Civil Liberties & Negotiations With Evil Overlooked
                    4. $ Cost of Always Being Ready: No Nuclear Pearl Harbor
III. The End of Bipartisanship & the "Year of Shocks": 1949
     A. The 1948 Election: Be Careful What You Ask For...
     B.  Soviet Bomb & Alger Hiss & "Loss" of China: Cold War in Asia
                    1. How Could US Possibly Fail? US Aid to Chiang Fails & Asia Firsters Cry Treason!
                    2. Alger Hiss:  Guilty? Link to FBI's Secret Dossier on Communist Espionage, Reasons not to Disclose Sources  
                    3. Setting for McCarthyism: The Second Red Scare: Link to McCarthy’s Attack on Acheson: "I Have in My Hand"
IV. "Korean Conflict": Domestic Context, Sponsorship & US Response
    A. Civil War (Syngman Rhee vs Kim Il-Sung) OR Perceived Soviet Master Plan: Changes in Scholarly Interpretation
    B. The "Munich Analogy" Revisited: USA Intervention
               1. HST Commits US Forces to UN Mission: No Declared War
               2. From Pusan Beyond Inchon: Crossing 38th Parallel: MacArthur Tries to Reunify Korea: ROLLBACK Red Tide!
               3. MacArthur's Response to Chinese Entry
                         a. Opposes "Limited War" Publicly:  Insubordination & Constitutional Principle
                         b. Relief & Reaction: Wrong War, Time, Place, Enemy
    C. Consequences: Containment Globalized & Militarized,  American-Chinese Relations Embittered (NSC-68)
               1. Response to Communist/Nat'list Uprisings Established
               2. Bloody "Proof" of "Monolithic Communist Conspiracy"
               3. Unconstitutional Warmaking & Permanent Readiness
V. Ike's Foreign Policy: Dulles' Massive Retaliation & Liberation?
    A. ARE THERE ANY REAL ALTERNATIVES TO PATIENT CONTAINMENT? NO!
    B. No More "Negative, Futile, Immoral" Containment!?
              1. Budget Cutting: Keep Financial Costs Down? Moral?
               2. Massive Retaliation: Go to the Brink? Nukes Credible?
               3. Then How Contain Communism? CIA Covert Interventions
               4. A. Dulles: "Hitherto Acceptable Norms": Iran/Guatemala

                        a. Contemporary NYT Coverage & Recent Revised NYT Assessment of US Role In Coup & to Leaked CIA After-Action Report

                        b. How Far May Good Justifiably Go to Overcome Evil?
                        c.  Consequences for US Credibility: Resembling the Enemy
              5. Empty Rhetoric vs. Reality: "Rollback" & Hungary '56

VI. Kennedy Foreign Policy: A Mixed Record of Arrogance & Prudence
    A. Universalism Rampant: JFK’s Inaugural Address (Link to Text)
    B. The Vienna Summit & the Berlin Wall
    C. The Cuban Missile Crisis,, '62: Rushing Toward Armageddon: Link to Speech
                  1. Responsibility for Inherited Bay of Pigs '61 (CIA)
                  2. US Options: Airstrike, Do Nothing, Negotiate Quietly?
                  3. Public Ultimatum & "Quarantine"
VII. Vietnam: The Logical Culmination of Containment Unrestrained
    A. Context: Decolonization, NATIONALISM & the Cold War
                 1. Decolonization: Aid Status Quo Allies or Nationalism? The Price for French Help in NATO 1950-54
                 2. French Collapse: Dienbienphu & Ike's Restraint
                 3. Opposition (Ho Chi Minh) Communist & NATIONALIST
                 4. Breaking Geneva Accords: SEATO & No Elections 1956
                 5. Sink or Swim with Ngo Dinh Diem: 1956-63: Any Way OUT?
                 6. The Kennedy/Diem Years: Repression w/o Reform
    B. Why did US Commit, Maintain, Expand & Fail? Quagmire!
                 1. The "Munich Analogy": Aggression Does not, Cannot Pay
                 2. Civil War or Aggression? Viable South Vietnam?
                 3. Domino Theory: If One Falls, All Fall: All the Same?
    C. What's Our Goal in Vietnam?? Not Economic Exploitation
                  1. Keep NVA/VC From Winning to Maintain Credibility!
                  2. Couldn't Provoke PRC or USSR Intervention: Limited War
   D. LBJ's Problem: Can't Withdraw; How Win? Send 500,000!?
                  1. Military Escalation after Decade of Policy Failure!
                  2. Tonkin Gulf Resolution: Radar Glitches & Deceit
                  3. Whose Will will crack?: Impact on Ordinary Soldiers & The Destruction of Postwar Consensus 
 
 

























POSTWAR POLITICS, ECONOMY & CULTURE TO THE "GREAT" SOCIETY

I. Postwar Boom: From Hardship to Prosperity: How?
    A. Reconversion/Demobilization: Fearing Depression
                   1. HST: Extend New Deal: Full Employment? Health Insurance?
                   2. Contrary Problem: Control Inflation & Interest Groups?
                   3. Strikes: UAW, USW, UMW, RR: Price-Wage Spiral Precedents
                   4. Gov't Control: Authority to Draft Strikers?
                   5. Partisan Bickering (1946): Had Enough?
    B. Rep. Sweep: Taft-Hartley Act's Clauses & Consequences
                   1. Forbids Closed Shops, Enables Limits to Union Shops
                   2. Effort to Limit Union Gains Enabled by Wagner Act
    C. Growth: '48-'68 REAL GNP Up 4%; Family Income Up 30%, '47-'56
    D. Avoid Depression, Jump-Start Boom: Reasons for Prosperity
                   1.The GI Bill of Rights  &-Pent-up Consumer demand
                                 a. Reward for Service: Investment in Future
                                 b. Mortgage & Educational Assistance for Vets: Success!
                                 c. Confidence: Homeowning/Fertility Rate Rise
                                 d. Home Ownership Rises: 44% 1940; 62% 1960
                                 e. Postponed Kids Arrive: Baby-Boomers' consumption
                                 f. Population Jumps 30%, 1945-1960
                                 g. Who Will Employ Baby-Boomers Later?
                    2. New Deal Safety Net: Downturns & Unemployment Pay
                    3. Military $ Up From $13 bn FY '50 To $44bn FY '52
                    4. Int'l Trade Dominance & Technological Innovation
     E. Income Redistributed?:No, But "Rising Tide Lifts All Boats"


II. 1948 Election: Underdog Truman's New Deal Coalition Fragments
    A. Will it Collapse?: "Dixiecrats": Strom Thurmond  & "Pink" Progressives: Henry Wallace
    B. Why He Wins: Truman Attacks: "Give 'em hell, Harry"
                    1. "Do-Nothing"(?) 80th Congress & Boring Tom Dewey
                    2. Motivation: Politics of Civil Rights: Isaac Woodard
                    3. Recognition of Israel: Jewish-American Votes
                    4. Fear of Renewed Recession: Trust Democrats
    C. Pyrrhic Victory at Home & Abroad: Stalling the Fair Deal
    D. The Evolving Southern Democrat/Republican Partial Coalition in Congress


III. President Eisenhower: The 1952 Election & After:  Republicans Confirm Internationalism
    A. Also Extends, Legitimates New Deal: Millions More Eligible for Social Security
    B. Cut & Balanced Budget, Failed to Lead on Civil Rights
    C. Public Works: Interstate Highways
IV. 1960 Election & The JFK Record: Proposals and Little Action
    A. JFK, Nixon, Catholics, Debates & Dead Voters?
    B. Legacy of Camelot & the JFK Assassination, 1963: How Sift Through Evidence? Why Do We Care?
                     1. Link to Site on Conspiracy Theories
V. How Had Depression, War & Cold War Changed America & Americans?
    A. What Consensus Did Vietnam Upset?
    B. Cold War Mindset: Victory Culture
    C. Economic Prosperity & Cultural Race & Gender Norms

 

VI. Materialism vs Idealism: A Consumer Culture
    A. Dispersing Affluence: National Pride: Advertising & TV
    B. Marketing: Morality of Hedonism & Rapid Obsolescence?
    C. Suburbs: From Farms & Cities to Conformity: "Levittowns"
    D. Woman's Place/Role?: A Cult of "Feminine Domesticity"
    E. Stevenson: Women Should Influence Man & Boy in the Humble Role of Housewife
    F. Feminism: Betty Friedan & NOW: Roles, Gains & Losses  Link to Recent News Article Describing Study of Divorce
    G. Seeking Meaning & Roots Amid Change: Religious Revival:  Can Faith Be Marketed?
    H. Meaning & Materialism: Riesman's The Lonely Crowd
                   1. Critic of Conformity, Corporate Life, Consumer Culture
                   2. Inner-Directed/Other-Directed
                   3. Docile Corporate Character in Popularity Market
                   4. Yet: Feasible Alternatives to Materialism?


VII. Examining the Critiques of the Prosperous, Conforming Fifties: Link to Analysis of How 50s Produced 60s
    A. The Great Society: Eliminate Poverty: Method? Materialism?
    B. Civil Rights Movement: Political & Social Equality, Econ?
    C. Youth Revolt: Political & Cultural Rejection
    D. Vietnam: Questioning Containment & the Cold War
    E. The Critiques' Contradictions & Accomplishments
    F. Were the Fifties So Bad or So Good After All?


VIII. Lyndon Johnson's Great Society: Link to "The War on Poverty" Speech
   A. Domestic Priority: Exploit Nat'l Grief: Enact Blocked Programs
               1. Poverty Programs: Job Corps, Head Start, VISTA
               2. Paying For It: Tax Reduction to Generate Revenue
               3. Electoral Distraction: A Choice, Not an Echo
   B. The Johnson Landslide & The Great Society's Triumph
               1. Medicare, Medicaid, Education Aid, Housing (HUD), Appalachia, NEA, NEH, Environment
                    2. Administrative Problems Amid Liberalism's Triumph: DID IT WORK? Was It Tried? Justice? Incentive?
                             a. Voting Constituency? Suburban Backlash?
                             b. A Legacy for '90s Democrats & Republicans
                             c. Civil Rights: Lagging Behind Grass-Roots Protest
                             d. Civil Rights Act (1964) & Voting Rights Act (1965)


 
    CRACKS ARE SHOWING: CIVIL RIGHTS, SIXTIES TUMULT & WATERGATE
I. Civil Rights: The "Second Reconstruction"
     A. Breakthroughs in Sports: Louis, Owens, Robinson, Russell...
     B. HST Integrates Armed Services, 1948: Executive Order 9981
     C. Supreme Court Leadership: Brown v. Board of Education (Link) 1954
             1. Thurgood Marshall Tests "Separate But Equal"
             2. Grass Roots Response to Eisenhower's Inhibitions
                               a. "Massive Resistance": Harry Byrd;  Southern Manifesto: 101/126 S; not LBJ, Gore Sr.
                               b. Media Coverage: Emmett Till Case....The Montgomery Bus Boycott: Rosa Parks
                               c. Nonviolent Passive Resistance: M. L. King Jr & SCLC, Religion & Politics
                               d. Govs. Orval Faubus (Ark) & George Wallace (Ala)
                               e. Greensboro, NC: Civil Disobedience by SNCC


                3. King v. "Bull" Connor in Birmingham, Ala: JFK Reacts
                4. March on DC, 8/28/63: "I Have A Dream" Speech; Leads to Civil Rights Act 1964
                5. The Campaign for Voting Rights: Freedom Summer, Mississippi; Alabama Literacy Test, 1965
II. From Triumph to Tragedy: Beyond The Voting Rights Act of 1965
     A. Consequences for LBJ's Democrats in South & Among Whites
     B. Why Riots: Watts, Chicago, Cleveland, Newark, Detroit... Context of Violence, Injustice & Law Enforcement
                 1. North Segregated too, but no shared cultural heritage
                 2. Collapse of Black Consensus: "Black Power" SNCC v King:. Internal Hypocrisy toward Female Members
III. 1968: A Traumatic Year as Trends Coalesce
     A. Youth Rebels: Fragmented Politics & Culture: The "New Left"
              1. Link to "Port Huron Statement": Berkeley FSM & Vietnam Catalyst
              2. Youth Culture: Sexual Revolution & "Counterculture": Link to Memoir from one Sixties Radical Who Now Rejects it
              3. Woodstock to Altamont: Collapse, Accomplishments, Impact?
     B. Vietnam: TET!: Military Defeat for VC; Pol Defeat for US & LBJ
     C. King & RFK Killed: RFK's Announcement of MLK's Death in Indianapolis
     D. Chicago DNC: Impatient Undemocratic Quest for Power
     E.  "Law and Order" Nixon: Peace with Honor?
IV. Nixon's Great Achievement: Triangular Diplomacy: Deténte
V. Nixon's Vietnam Strategy: Retain an Independent South Vietnam
      A. Defuse Antiwar Protests through "Vietnamization"
               1. Reduce US Army Component, Increase USAF Component, Increased Vietnamese Ground Component
      B. Force N. Viet To Compromise: Through Detente? Bombing? Cambodia?
               1. PRC & USSR Communist Too; Bomb More & Further North?
               2. Cambodia's Domestic Consequences: Kent State
               3. Peace is at hand: The Christmas Bombings
VI. Nixon's Domestic Policy: Economic & Political Trials
    A. "Stagflation": High Inflation & High Unemployment: Keynes Was Wrong
               1. Legacy of Vietnam & Reduced Int'l Competitiveness
               2. Energy Dependence on Middle East; Employing Baby-Boomers
               3. Decreasing Family Income: More Units re Divorce
    B. Getting Re-elected: "Silent Majority" & "Southern Strategy"
              1. Supreme Court Nominations: Battling Warren Court: Ruling That Banned Prayer in Schools (Engel v. Vitale, 1962)
              2. Watergate: CREEP Coverup: What did Pres. Know & when?
                           a. Tapes, "Saturday Night Massacre" & Resignation
                           b. Is Democracy Strong Or Does This Propel Despair?
 
 
 
    RECOVERING FROM VIETNAM & WATERGATE: ALTERNATE PRESCRIPTIONS
I. Recover Power Through Repentance: Carter's Agenda After Vietnam
    A. Human Rights: Freeze Aid to Dictators; Panama Canal Treaty
    B. Middle East: Triumph of Sadat & Carter's Personal Diplomacy
            1. Yet A Client's Collapse: Iran
            2. Afghanistan: Soviet Adventurism and Cold War Response
    C. Cold War Returns & Stagflation Continues: Carter's Woes
II. Reagan: Morality in Recovered Strength, Will & Defense
    A. Election, Re-election & Domestic Policy: "Teflon President"
            1. Personality & Record in California & Washington
            2. Iranian Hostage Crisis & Demographic Shift S & W
            3. The Moral Majority: Religion & Politics
            4. "Reaganomics": A Balanced Budget Plan?: The Reagan Economic Argument
                      a. Cut Taxes, Domestic $, Deficit;  Increase Defense Spending
                      b. Constituents: Social, Fiscal, Economic, Military Hawks
             5. Who Got What They Wanted? A More Complicated View of Reagan
   B. Reagan's Enemies: The Decade of Greed? Or of Jealousy?
   C. Renew Cold War: Challenge Source of Global Evil: Evil Empire
               1. Lessons of Vietnam: Rambo--We Can (& Should) Act
               2. Issues: Afg, Pol, KAL 007, Nukes, Grenada, Nicaragua
               3. Sovt Decline & Retreat under Gorbachev: Reagan Peacemaker?
               4. START & INF: Real Nuclear Arms Reductions
               5. Did We Win Cold War? Weakened Economy: Political Willpower?
               6. Still #1??: Crisis of Pol/Social/Econ Values
    D. Iran-Contra Scandal
III. USA Today: WHAT DO YOU WANT/EXPECT?
    A. Bush Sr.'s World: End of the Cold War, Panama, &  Gulf War One (Link to Bush Speech)
    B. Balancing Domestic & Foreign Priorities: Clinton's Agenda
    C. Assessing Fifties' Critiques: Gains? Losses?
    D. Issues Loom: Security, Immigrants, Welfare, Health Care, Crime?
               1. How Has America's Role in the World Changed?
               2. Has Growth of Government Role Been Correctly Implemented?
               3. Does Democracy/Capitalism Remain Resilient amid Fear?
               4. Our Divisions at Home and With Our Allies: Econ/Race/Values/Gender: Legit/Real?
               5. Do We Trust Political Leaders? Consequences?
                           a. Voter Cynicism, Turnout, & Politics of Race/Class
                           b. Pres/Congress: Leaders or Hogs at the Trough?
                           c. Economic, Political, Social Hedonism: MY RIGHTS!!
                           d. Life Beyond Government: Is it Possible? Where Get Solutions? Politics?
                           e. Rights Possible Without Responsibilities? Freedom Possible without Restraint?
                           f. 60's/Relativist Lessons: Tolerant Conformists: PC
                6. Can We/Should We Keep Borders Open to New Immigrants?
                7. Liberty & Justice: Poverty, Wealth, Health & Crime
                8. Change? Progress? Hope? Fear in the Aftermath of 9-11

END