102
INDIANAPOLIS REGIONAL CENTER PLAN 2020
PLANNING DOWNTOWNfS FUTURE TODAY
APPENDIX A: HISTORY OF DEVELOPMENT
Kinderhook, Germantown, Cotton Town and
Stringtown; and suburbs such as Brightwood,
Belmont, Mount Jackson, Haughville, Woodruff
Place and Irvington began to flourish. Mayor
John Caven (among the city's most popular,
having been elected to five two-year terms)
personally drove the Street Railway Company's
first mule-drawn streetcar down Illinois Street
Union Depot inaugurating the city's first urban
transportation system.
The public school system kept pace with the
dramatic population increase (the greatest
increase in the city's history in terms of
percentage increase) under the outstanding
leadership of Superintendent A.C. Shortridge.
Parochial schools flourished, Indiana Medical
College was founded and the city's first business
college opened its doors offering, among other
things, the city's longest title: The Indianapolis
Practical Business, Military and Lecture College.
Representative buildings of this era are Saint
John's Catholic Church (1871) at 121 South
Capitol Avenue, Morrison Opera Place (1871)
at 47 South Meridian Street and the Nickum/
Holstein House/James Whitcomb Riley Home
(1872) at 528 Lockerbie Street.
1873-1888: POST-WAR DEPRESSION
Indianapolis had to catch its breath. The Civil
War economy and the momentum that carried
it into the early 1870s had been characterized
by hectic and uninterrupted growth. The bubble
suddenly burst with the startling failure of the
New York Banking House of Jay Cooke and
Col and the government's return to the Gold
Standard. Its unexpectedness set off the
financial panic of 1873
Industry virtually ground to a halt in Indianapolis.
Statewide, over 1,000 businesses failed. Over-
extended real-estate investors and individual
entrepreneurs like James Woodruff were hard hit.
New industrial buildings remained unfinished
Even prosperous businesses cut production.
The Panic of 1873 engendered a strong
resentment against the Eastern banks and
exchanges that were suspected of controlling
the economy to their advantage. One result
was the formation of the Greenback Party that
exemplified the strong feeling that had emerged
for government control of the currency.
Despite the recession (or perhaps due in part to
it) the retail sector of the economy consolidated
and began to expand. Lyman S. Ayres bought
out N.R. Smith and Company's One-Price, Wide
Awake Trade Palace, the When Building (now
the Ober Building) opened, to be followed shortly
by the H.P. Wasson, L. Strauss and William H.
Block establishments.
In 1876, Col. Eli Lilly opened a small
pharmaceutical firm at 15 West Pearl Street.
quickly grew from a staff of three managed by his
son Josiah to a major local business employing
100 workers and a dozen traveling salesmen.
This was only the beginning. Eli Lilly and
Company has been a major factor in the city's
economic, political and social growth for over
100 years, the complete history of its impact on
Indianapolis having yet to be written.
Mayor John Caven did not wait for the economy
to heal itself. In an effort to put more people to
work, he sought ways to attract new business to
the city. He proposed an actively promoted the
building of a Belt Railroad around the southern
half of the city that would connect all the railroads
coming into the city with Union Depot and each
other. The plan was implemented after several
false starts and helped position Indianapolis for
its next phase of development despite having
rendered several communities south of the Circle
virtually inaccessible due to train blockage of
access roads.
Several buildings constructed during this era
provide a visible reflection of the times: Pierson
Griffiths House/Kemper House (1873) at 1028
North Delaware, Hammond Block (1874) at 301
Massachusetts, City Market (1886), Indiana State
House (1888) and Union Railroad Station (1888).
Saint John's Catholic Church, 1903
Indiana Historical Society, Bass Photo Collection, 841
Union Station, 1903
Indiana Historical Society, Bass Photo Collection, 824
Union Station Depot