100
INDIANAPOLIS REGIONAL CENTER PLAN 2020
PLANNING DOWNTOWNfS FUTURE TODAY
APPENDIX A: HISTORY OF DEVELOPMENT
Persistent pressure from both sides resulted in
a political compromise (and a financial disaster)
called the Mammoth Improvement Bill that was
signed by Governor Noah Noble in 1836. The bill
unfortunately so totally ignored basic economic
facts that it committed a state with annual
revenues of $75,000 to a $10,000,000 bond over
25 years at five percent interest. Work on
Central Canal was halted in August 1839 when
the General Assembly learned that it had already
amassed a debt of $14 million set against a
combined tax and revenue income of $106,000.
Already in the throes of the financial Panic
1837, the State was forced to declare bankruptcy
and an abortive attempt was even made to
abolish Indianapolis' town government due to its
excessive cost of $3,000 a year.
One bright spot on the local scene was the
completion of the Madison-Indianapolis Rail Line,
the construction of which had been turned over
to a private company whose chief engineer was
Thomas Armstrong Morris. Its arrival presaged a
new era of dramatic growth in the capital.
The Governor James Brown Ray House (c.
1835), which has since been moved to 302 North
Park Avenue, is a representative structure of this
era.
1847-1860: THE RAILROAD ERA
The railroads had arrived and Indianapolis' 7,000
citizens rejoiced in the promise of prosperity.
In perspective, however, the results of the
1847 town election carried at least as much
significance not because it elected the capital's
first mayor (Samuel Henderson) or approved
first town charter, but because it set the course
education in the community until the present day.
Whereas Indiana had been the first in the Union
to ensure in its constitution that schools would
be gratis and open to all, it failed to adopt a
funding mechanism for the system and as noted
by the Census of 1840, had the highest rate of
illiteracy among the northern states. The idea of
tax-supported schools was strongly backed by
the town's establishment including Samuel Merril,
Calvin Fletcher, Dr. Isaac Coe, James Blake and
Judge Isaac Blackford. Opposition (particularly
at the State level) was also strong. When the
votes were finally counted, Indianapolis
adopted a tax-supported public school system
with better than 95 percent of the vote. The
following year, the State also adopted a publicly-
financed school system, but with only 56 percent
voting in favor.
Mayor Henderson completed his term in
1849 and immediately left the town for
California's promise of gold, ridiculing the
notion that Indianapolis would ever become
a railroad center. History proved him one of
the community's worst prognosticators as
seven lines had entered the capital by 1855,
connecting it with all major population centers
of the Midwest as well as the lucrative East
Coast market. The Union Depot on South Illinois
Street, built by Thomas Morris, was unique in the
country because all rail traffic entering or leaving
Indianapolis passed through it.
The railroads not only brought prosperity to
Indianapolis, but were the threads that linked
it with the nation's economic and society. The
population more than doubled between 1850
and 1860. Prosperity was evident in the number
and variety of retail establishments it supported.
Clemens Vonnegut's hardware store opened as
did the H. Lieber Col, the New York Store, the
Eagle Clothing Store, agencies for the Singer
and Wheeler and the Wilson Sewing Machine
companies and the Samuel Merrill Bookstore.
Indianapolis was fast becoming a wholesaling
and manufacturing center. Quickly recognizing
the strategic importance of the town's situation
as a rail hub connecting it to remove areas were
wholesale grocers Little and Co. and Schnull
and Col, wholesale druggists Henneman and
Duzen and the Eagle Machine Works, makers
of farm threshers and separators. Over a dozen
hotels thrived during the era, the most lavish of
which was that of Hervey Bates on the corner
of Washington and Illinois Streets.
(The Bates
House was the setting for a memorable address
by President Lincoln and was eventually sold to
Henry Claypool for $106,000.)
Northwestern Christian University opened its
doors in 1855 uniquely promising admission
to all regardless of sex, race or color. (Its
principal backer was an outstanding leader in the
community, Ovid Butler, for whom the University
was later renamed.)
By the mid-1850s most of the streets in the Mile
Square had been improved. After a false start
abruptly ended with the Beer Riots of 1855,
Indianapolis established a viable police force
and by 1859, had effectively brought the
town's
strongly independent volunteer fire departments
Tomlinson Hall and City Market, 1906
Indiana Historical Society, Bass Photo Collection