1998 Lisa Wesley '82, Concordia Lutheran
1999 Mike Haviland '71, Muncie Central
2000 Mike Haviland '71, Muncie Central
2001 Bryant Branigan '94, North Central-Indianapolis
2002 Lisa Wesley '82, Concordia Lutheran
2003 Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton
2004 Brad Peterson '96, Concordia Lutheran
2005 Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton
2006 Tom Knudson '81, Fort Wayne Northrop
2007 Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton  
2008 Joe Brinker '98, Fort Wayne Carroll