1974 Mike Hawley '68, Fort Wayne Snider
1998 Mike Holman '78, Lawrence Central
1999 Charlie Owen '59, Yorktown
2000 Charles Koeppen '68, Carmel
2001 Mike Holman '78, Lawrence Central
2002 Mike Holman '78, Lawrence Central
2003 Mike Holman '78, Lawrence Central
2004 Matt Osborne '92, Centerville
2005 Mike Holman '78, Lawrence Central
2006 Ken Hittson, '88, Richmond
2007 Rob Kratoska '90, Roncalli
2008 Matt Osborne '92, Centerville