1971 Joseph Saine '50, Peru
1997 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
1998 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
1999 Jim Clark '68, Homestead
2000 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2001 Kyle Stoffel '91, Carroll
2002 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2003 Mike Bostic '96, Carmel
2004 Mike Bostic '96, Carmel
2005 Barry Weaver, '75, Jay County
2006 Jim Clark, '68, Homestead
2007 Randy Ecker '79, Centerville