1985 David Stroud '72, Warren Central
1990 Brett Stoker '83, Tipton
1998 Dave Cook '85, Hamilton Southeastern
1999 Todd Croy '86, Whiteland Community
2000 Joe Tilford '69, Indiana Lutheran
2001 Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central
2002 Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central
2003 Jennifer Mascari '99, Culver Academies
2004 Joe Tilford '69, Indianapolis Lutheran
2005 Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central
2006 Paris Seibold '78, Huntington North
2007 Scott Hall '99, Pendleton Heights
2008 Scott Hall '99, Pendleton Heights