1970 Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel
1973 Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel
1974 Phillip Sullivan, '63, Union City
1975 Jack Jorden, '67, Yorktown
1982 Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel
1983 George Hultgren, '49, Michigan City
1985 John Bingaman, '62, Kokomo
1986 John Bingaman, '62, Kokomo
1989 Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel
1990 Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel
1998 Jerry Newland, '70, New Castle Chrysler
1999 Ted Oliger, '65, Cambridge City Lincoln
2000 Jim Slain, '84, Garrett
2001 Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond
2002 Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond
2003 Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond
2004 Mike Moore, '68, Noblesville
2005 Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond
2006 Bill Mattingly, '76, Indianapolis Cathedral
2007 Keith Turner, '95, Carmel
2008 Brad Baughman, '79, Brown County