1958 Virgil Kirkpatrick '52, Bluffton
1959 Doug Adams '49, Michigan City
1960 Virgil Kirkpatrick '52, Bluffton
1961 Robert Straight '50, Huntington
1962 Von Jameson '36, Middletown
1963 Robert Straight '50, Huntington
1964 Robert Straight '50, Huntington
1965 Jerry Oliver '53, Indianapolis Washington
1966 Doug Adams '49, Michigan City
1967 Joseph Stanley '59, Liberty
1968 John Cross '55, Bluffton
1969 Harry Allison '49, Crown Point
1970 Doug Adams '49, Michigan City
1971 Kirby Overman '62, Batesville
1972 Myron Dickerson '56, Connersville
1973 Kirby Overman '62, New Albany
1974 Phillip Snodgress '63, Union County
1975 Irvin Pratt '54, Northridge
1976 Robert Fuller '62, Highland
1977 George Griffith '64, South Bend LaSalle
1978 Stanley Neal '65, Washington
1979 Paul Curtis '56, Crawfordsville
1980 Robert Fuller '62, Anderson Highland
1981 Robert Heady '64, Shenandoah
1982 James Irwin '65, Southern Wells
1983 Basil Mawbey '64, Connersville
1984 James Hammel '67, Lake Central
1985 George Griffith '64, Richmond
1986 Steven Bennett '70, Lafayette Central
1987 Steven Bennett '70, Lafayette Central - Robert Kovatch '71, Indiana School for the Deaf
1988 James Hahn '79, Concord
1989 John Keefer '65, Lawrence North
1990 James Hahn '79, Concord
1991 Jim Howell '80, Mount Vernon
1992 George Griffith '64, Richmond
1993 Robert Heady '64, Carmel
1994 Michael Drews '81, Muncie Central
1995 James East '62, Merrillville
1996 Christopher Johnson '88, Fort Wayne Bishop Dwenger - James Hammel, '67, Lake Central
1997 Paul Keller '78, Delta
1998 Joe Bradburn '89, Yorktown
1999 Keith Hipskind '79, Greensburg
2000 Moe Smedley '66, Marion
2001 Al Gooden '81, Harding
2002 Wayne Barker '89, Bluffton
2003 Basil Mawbey '64, Cass
2004 Chris Benedict '89, Columbia City
2005 Matt Fine '98, Muncie Central
2006 Craig Teagle '86, Jay County
2007 Jim Gish '95, Northwestern
2008 Jim Shannon '82, New Albany