1984 Mel Wysong '75, Marion
1994 Greg Dikos '80, Penn
1998 Bill Stoudt '71, Pendleton Heights
1999 Bill Nixon '62, Plymouth
2000 Bob Stecher '68, Anderson Highland
2001 Don Sherman '63, Huntington
2002 Jim Turner '82, Logansport
2003 Bill Stoudt '71, Pendleton Heights
2004 Brian Dudley '80, Wapahani
2005 Brian Dudley '80, Wapahani
2006 Robert Shinkan '75, Munster
2007 Greg Dikos '80, Penn
2008 Eric Lentz '90, Carmel