1979 Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson
1983 Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson
1984 Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson
1997 James Garrett, '71, Penn
1998 Scott Herring, '92, Yorktown
1999 Scott Herring, '92, Yorktown
2000 John Engle, '65, Jay County
2001 Jim Garrett, '71, Penn
2002 Jim Garrett, '71, Penn
2003 Jim Garrett, '71, Penn
2004 Jim Garrett, '71, Penn
2005 Jim Garrett, '71, Penn
2006 Bill Mattingly, '76, Indianapolis Cathedral
2007 Ken Kelly, '79, Carmel