1997 Mitzi Owens, '81, Avon
1998 Chris Schnepp, '88, Hamilton Southeastern
1999 Scott Evans, '90, Westfield
2000 Mark Nirrengarten, '92, Avon
2001 Sue Rager, '72, Jay County
2003 Michael Whisler, '79, Valparaiso
2004 Michael Whisler, '79, Valparaiso
2005 James Sensibaugh, '96, Chesterton
2006 Scott Coil, '00, Lowell
2007 James Sensibaugh, '96, Chesterton