1974 Fred Ginther '63, Muncie Northside
1975 James Cartwright '61, Muncie Southside
1980 Donald Patton, '69, Delta
1981 Donald Patton '69, Delta
1982 Donald Patton '69, Delta
1983 Donald Patton '69, Delta
1984 Donald Patton '69, Delta
1985 Donald Patton '69, Delta
1987 Dennis Hays '79, Bellmont
1988 Dennis Hays '72, Bellmont
1990 John Smith '73, Muncie Southside
1998 Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown
1999 Andy Hobbs '91, Peru
2000 Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown
2001 Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown
2002 Ron Anderson '73, Winchester
2003 Lance Wildoner '94, Harrison
2004 Craig Standish '94, Eastern (Greentown)
2005 Rex Leavitt '71, Elwood Community
2006 Scott Schwarz '88, East Central
2007 Scott Schwarz '88, East Central
2008 Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown