1998 David Jarvis '76, Greensburg
1999 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2000 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2001 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2002 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2003 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2004 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2005 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2006 Kathy Kinghorn, '77, Indianapolis Arsenal Technical
2007 Tim Cleland '87, Delta
2008 Pat Slama '69, Zionsville