1957 William McClain, '50, Noblesville
1958 Charles Myers, '50, Huntington
1959 Victor Overman, '46, Michigan City
1960 William Lynch, '49, New Castle
1961 Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond
1962 Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond
1963 Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond
1964 Robert Baker, '51, Madison Heights
1965 Jack Lowe, '57, North Liberty
1966 Donald Wiggs, '59, Winchester
1967 Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond
1968 James Hollibaugh, '51, Logansport
1969 Steve Lookabaugh, '64, Delta
1970 Ted Huber, '67, Hamilton Heights
1971 William Siderewicz, '61, Martinsville
1972 William Doba, '62, Mishawaka
1973 Robert Van Camp, '50, South Bend Washington
1974 William Doba, '62, Mishawaka
1975 David Land, '69. Wes-Del
1976 William Nixon, '62, Plymouth
1977 William Nixon, '62, Plymouth
1978 Victor Overman, '46, Brownsburg
1979 Myron Dickerson, '61, Fort Wayne Northside
1980 Larry Wright, '63, Sheridan
1981 Leland Etzler, '62, Woodlan
1982 Frank O'Shea, '63, McCutcheon
1983 Joseph Jackson, '55, Anderson Highland
1984 George Conn, '72, Concord
1985 Myrson Dickerson, '61, Wawasee
1986 Michael Hawley, '68, Fort Wayne Snider
1987 Larry Wright, '63, Sheridan
1988 Mark Surface, '68, Marion
1989 Gerald Vlasic, '62, Hammond Bishop Noll
1990 David Wilhelm, '69, Southwood
1991 John Fallis, '66, Greencastle
1992 Daniel Robinson, '73, Northwestern
1993 Ernie Beck, '59, West Lafayette
1994 Martin Huber, '77, Bremen
1995 John Hendryx, '86, Carroll
1996 John Hendryx, '86, Carroll
1997 Donald Willard, '64, Knightstown
1998 Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan
1999 Bob Gaddis, '78, Evansville Reitz
2000 Grant Zgunda, '90, Delta
2001 Grant Zgunda, '90, Delta
2002 John Hochstetler, '92, Muncie Central
2003 John Hochstetler, '92, Muncie Central
2004 Bob Gaddis, '78, Columbus East
2005 Larry "Bud" Wright, '63. Sheridan
2006 Tim Dawson, '81, Concord
2007 Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan