1974 Michael Hawley, '68, Fort Wayne Snider
1976 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1977 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1978 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1979 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1981 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1982 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1987 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1988 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1993 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1996 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1997 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1998 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
1999 Tom Miller, '85, Penn
2000 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
2001 Doug Snyder, '73, New Prairie
2002 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
2003 Charles Koeppen, '68, Carmel
2004 Bruce Kendall, '75, Mount Vernon
2005 Rick Torres, '00, Andrean
2006 Rick Torres, '00, Andrean
2007 Randy Fife, '82, Seymour